Frustrated with the health-care system? Don’t know where to turn for help? Want more on the human side of health care? We’ve got you covered.
Let consumer decide their pain treatment
The politicians in Tallahassee are again bantering insurance reform. More precisely, they are considering revamp of the state’s controversial personal injury protection insurance.
For those of you new to the state or living under a rock, it’s the same insurance that has led to all the lawyer radio advertisements that practically beg you to save their phone number on your speed dial. It’s insurance that has led to the 1-800-PAIN jingle that you can probably sing in the shower and the same insurance that’s led to a very cozy relationship between chiropractors, lawyers and pain management doctors.
Let me stop right here and disclose that I am a licensed massage therapist in the state of Florida. I have worked for two chiropractors -- one for a couple of years and one for about a week. I quit working for the latter when I felt she was practicing questionable medicine.
That said, I have worked on many personal injury clients at the chiropractor’s office. I know how it works. Some of them were attorney referrals. Some of them weren’t.
I also am a Florida motorist and have a teenage driver. I am just as interested as the next guy in keeping my costs manageable. I was involved in a no-fault-of-mine auto accident a few weeks ago and have not hired a lawyer and have not sought unnecessary treatment. I have not received an MRI and did not go to an emergency room. I did receive one massage the day after the accident for neck and shoulder pain at a chiropractor’s office, a necessary move in my opinion, considering my profession.
Under current proposals in Tallahassee, advice of the National Institutes of Neurological Disorders and Stroke regarding sensible self-care regarding back pain would be ignored, however, and anyone involved in an auto accident would need to visit an emergency room or doctor within 72 hours of an accident or insurance wouldn’t have to cover.
Never mind that pain can worsen over 72 hours. Never mind for back pain and injury that the NINDS does not necessarily suggest jamming into the ER for non-life-threatening injury, but rather using a solid approach to self-care, stating:
“Treatment involves using analgesics, reducing inflammation, restoring proper function and strength to the back, and preventing recurrence of the injury. Most patients with back pain recover without residual functional loss. Patients should contact a doctor if there is not a noticeable reduction in pain and inflammation after 72 hours of self-care.”
This would be sensible. Instead, Tallahassee is merely suggesting trading medical claims at the chiropractor’s office for more expensive medical claims at the ER and MD office, if you ask me.
It’s going to result in people racing even quicker to the doctor, probably getting an even higher level of invasive treatment of cortisone injections, MRI and CT scans or prescriptions for the ever-popular and very addictive pain pills and muscle relaxers, which seem a favorite of Florida physicians instead.
I am shocked by the number of my massage clients who have to pay out of pocket for massage after their own physician refuses to write a prescription for it, but are totally willing to shoot them up with cortisone or dole out a pain pill. (Possibly because the physician doesn’t offer massage at their location.)
If Tallahassee wants to reform anything, I would suggest reforms that allow patient true freedom and choice.
Instead of forcing patients into doctors’ offices or ERs for pain management, how about allowing the client to choose where they go? I would suggest that a fair number of patients would opt for much cheaper options such as yoga classes, massage therapy, acupuncture or water exercise therapies instead of the expensive lawyer-MRI-doctor-pain pill gravy train we have rolling now.
It seems Tallahassee’s “reforms” are just fewer options for the patients who need it most.
Kumari Kelly is a licensed massage therapist and can be reached at kumari_kelly@yahoo.com.